This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Dear reader,

To Kill a Mockingbird is widely cited as one of the greatest works of fiction ever published and it’s likely to be one of the most read novels we have covered on the show.

As Dominic said, it's hard to think of many books published since 1960 that have had such an impact on generation upon generation. Many of you are likely to have read it as teenagers or studied it at school, with this tale of racial injustice during the Jim Crow era of the 1930s Deep South leaving a mark on so many people.

And yet, as an adult, this book remains just as powerful. As I admitted on the show, I found myself sobbing on a train in front of bemused commuters while re-reading. 

It was fascinating to delve into how much of the story had echoes of the author’s real life. There were a number of prominent racist legal trials and lynchings happening in Harper Lee's community as she was growing up, while her father was – like Atticus Finch – also a lawyer and local politician. The character of Dill is also largely modelled on her childhood friend Truman Capote, no less.

Lee's father, Amasa Coleman Lee, even defended a black father and son in court in 1919 after they were accused of murdering a white storekeeper. They were found guilty and hanged.

The character of Atticus has become a literary hero yet he’s also been called a “plaster saint” and a “white saviour”. For a novel that remains so widely acclaimed, there have been a number of critics who have attempted to tear down To Kill a Mockingbird. Some describe the novel as having too simplistic a world view, others write it off as “a children’s book”.

Maybe it’s a symptom of the fact that the book has become so ingrained within American history (often topping lists of America’s favourite novel) and tackles such difficult subject matters – racism, class, the legacy of war, the importance of the law – that there are many possible lines of attack.

Lee never wrote another book (discounting the controversial “follow-up” Go Set a Watchman). Perhaps, as Dominic suggested, she set such a high standard for herself that she thought: “Sod it, I’m not going to even bother.”

This makes Lee part of the select group of authors who have had huge popularity with just one published novel. Which other writers can you think of in this category? Did you find yourself wanting more from such writers or can one hit novel sometimes be enough for some authors? Write in and share your thoughts for next week’s newsletter by emailing: [email protected].

Finally, in addition to our usual Book Notes, reviews and recommendations, we have a special treat for you all – a chance to win an audiobook token! More details on that below.

Until next time,

If you enjoyed To Kill a Mockingbird

Some more recommendations for your list

📚 Other Voices, Other Rooms by Truman Capote – Lee based the portrayal of Dill Harris on Capote, a childhood friend. He, in turn, shaped a character in this, his first novel, around Lee. We discussed their connection in our The Rest is History books miniseries on Capote’s In Cold Blood, which you can listen to here.

📚 Intruder in the Dust by William Faulkner – Dominic and Tabby cited Faulkner’s writing on race in the Deep South several times in the episode. This story centres on an elderly black farmer arrested for the murder of a white man.

📚 Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry by Mildred D. Taylor – Another book set in the south during the Great Depression and seen through the eyes of a child, this time an African American girl, Cassie Logan, whose family face racial injustice.

📚 The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas – A modern YA book published in 2017 that tackles the racism still faced by many young black people today, as a 16-year-old witnesses her unarmed friend being shot by a white police officer.

Win a Penguin audiobook!

For the next five weeks, we’re giving you the chance to win a Penguin audiobook. We'll be offering 100 free codes a week to reclaim against classics from Jane Eyre to Dubliners.

Here's how you can win: The first 100 people to take part in our poll will be sent an audiobook code to listen to Jane Eyre. The competition will close at 9am (UK time) on Monday November 23 and winners will be notified that day. You will have three days to redeem your audiobook before the code expires on Wednesday November 25 at 23:59 GMT.

To enter, answer the poll below. Only entries that are clicked from the newsletter email will be counted. Those coming via a web version of this post cannot be registered.

In our Jane Eyre episode, the presenters praised the finely-matched relationship between Jane and Mr Rochester, but some of you felt he wasn't the right partner for Jane. What's your view?

Click to vote – Please LEAVE YOUR NAME if you comment, so we can share your thoughts in next week's newsletter

Login or Subscribe to participate

Notes on… To Kill a Mockingbird

❝

Writing about Harper Lee’s masterpiece, the author Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie said: “The best novels are those that are important without being like medicine; they have something to say, are expansive and intelligent but never forget to be entertaining and to have character and emotion at their centre.” If you feel like you’ve read a few too many books that tasted like medicine recently, why not try Lee’s book…

“There are a lot of critics, frankly, who love to be negative about much-loved books because they think, ‘I'm going to tell everybody why this thing that they love is actually massively overrated and worthless’,” said Dominic. He added: “The idea that you're going to sit there as a grown-up and sneer at this… I mean, fine, if it makes you that happy, great, do it. But obviously, loads of people love this for a reason. And it's lasted for decades and presumably will continue to do so because it's a very well-written story.”

  • Despite facing criticism from its release in 1960 to today, To Kill a Mockingbird is regularly voted a favourite around the world. The presenters shared their thoughts on why it remains loved by so many. Why do you think its popularity has endured?

  • Author Flannery O’Connor was among those who criticised this book on its release, writing: “I think for a child's book it does all right. It's interesting that all the folks that are buying it don't know they're reading a child's book.” Dominic questioned the idea that Lee's story should be denigrated in this way. “I think a finely crafted children's book is just as valuable and precious a thing as a finely crafted adult one,” he said. Do you agree? If so, what are the best examples of this and why?

  • Despite such criticism, the novel’s popularity has rarely waned and it still reportedly sells almost a million copies a year. Why is there sometimes such a disconnect between public and critical opinion?

The narrative voice comes from six-year-old Scout and also her older self. “We have our two Scouts and the young Scout allows us to see the absurdity and hypocrisy of racism, but then the older Scout, her reflections provide the moral clarity of the novel,” said Tabby.

  • The mixing of perspectives isn’t unique (see books such as Jane Eyre and Rebecca, as the presenters noted). But in the case of To Kill a Mockingbird, some critics have called the voice jumbled and inconsistent. What was your experience of the narrative? Does flitting between these two voices work? Where is this done well in literature?

  • The perspective of an adoring daughter is key in the portrayal of Atticus, who is revered as a great literary hero by some, and over-simplistic by critics such as Thomas Mallon, who named him a “plaster saint”. There is also something Christ-like about him, Tabby said. How do you view the character of Atticus Finch?

  • “What's wrong with the fact that he is an almost perfectly likeable character?” asked Tabby. Do we sometimes needlessly look for flaws in characters? Or do you feel Lee paints Atticus in an overly sympathetic way, perhaps in part because he was inspired by her father?

  • “This book needs Boo Radley,” says Tabby. Why do you think the presence of Boo Radley is key to To Kill a Mockingbird? What, in your view, is the symbolism of this character?

“You've got a very kind of dislocated, fractured environment in which white Southerners looked at their newly emancipated black counterparts with deep suspicion and dislike often,” said Dominic, setting out the historical landscape of the book, which takes place in the Deep South during the Great Depression. “[There’s] that sense of racial superiority, which people like the Ewells have, this ingrained idea of white supremacy. We're talking only about two generations on from the end of the Civil War.”

  • Still popular in schools more than 65 years after being published, this novel is often a starting point for youngsters to learn about everything from the history of slavery and racism to the American Civil War and the Great Depression. If you read this as a young person, what did it teach you? As an adult, what do you think the book portrays well about this period in history?

  • “There are little ways in which you start as you read the book and you're aware of all this history, you see how this is woven in,” said Dominic. “And Harper Lee doesn't make a huge deal of it. It's just there.” Does Lee’s approach of weaving dark history through the eyes of a child work? Were there moments you wished she had gone further?

  • “The language makes people feel uncomfortable because of the use of racial epithets, the N-word most obviously,” said Dominic. Not to include such language would be “bonkers”, he said, as it would mis-represent that moment in time. This is a point of view shared by civil rights leader Andrew Young. Where do you stand? If a similar book was written and published today, do you think the same decision would or should be made?

  • Lee is writing from the perspective of a white, Southern woman who grew up in an era where black people were still being lynched. How well do you think Lee depicts the black characters in the book?

  • It’s also a story about class and Lee uses dialogue and idiom to illustrate this. The author has been accused of stereotyping for this use of slang like “ain’t” and “yessum” and colloquialisms, including the prevalence of the words like “trash”. How well do you think Lee handles the different voices of her characters? How do you see class portrayed in this novel?

  • “Harper Lee may draw a thick strong line between right and wrong, but she allows for the fact that people will wander either side of it,” says the writer Sam Jordison. How do you interpret this analysis? Which characters would you say “wander either side” of right and wrong?

  • Can you understand those who say she is soft on the racism of some of her characters? What books would you recommend to others that you believe do a better job of exploring these issues?

The quote that says it all

“You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view... Until you climb inside of his skin and walk around in it.”

Atticus’s viewpoint on understanding and empathy is one that is at the heart of Lee’s novel, but it’s an attitude that has proved divisive. But what quote stayed with you? Email us and let us know.

Who should you give this to?

The Scout in your family, who’s looking to make sense of the world around them? Someone who is looking to understand the importance of writing for children? A despondent lawyer who needs a pep talk?

Who would you share this with?

Tell us what book fellow members should pick up next by sending two or three sentences about your novel of choice and we’ll feature as many as we can in future weeks… Email [email protected].

  • Francine calls for you to pick up Human Acts by Han Kang. “This book was incredible. The prose, the diction, I found myself in true awe. More people should read it.”

  • The Long Ships by Frans Gunnar Bengtsson is “one of my favourite books ever, so fun to read”, says Joe. “The author wrote it with the stated purpose of writing a fun novel about Vikings.”

  • Greg says Pachinko by Min Jin Lee is his favourite book of the last few years, adding: “The history, the characters and the story of a Korean woman living through Japanese occupation, war and life as a Korean in post-war Japan was compelling from start to finish.”

Reviewers’ corner

We can’t wait to see your responses to To Kill a Mockingbird. Write in to [email protected] with ‘review’ in the subject line and tell us whether you loved Scout’s narration and your thoughts on Atticus Finch. But first, your correspondence on Master and Commander.

Your polls

After a book packed with tricky terminology, last week we asked if you like to read complicated stories – the majority of you (56%) said it’s a balance and you like some knotty moments, but not too many.

Steph summarised the feelings of many of you, saying: “I like looking up terminology when reading books set in different areas of the world because it gives me a chance to learn about other cultures. But too much technical jargon just feels like the author is showing off!” And Steve made a good point: “It might come in useful in scrabble one day.”

Some of you, like Paul, are always up for the challenge: “I helped my dad write his sea-going memoirs, and once made the mistake of using the wrong words in a nautical description. Boy did I hear about that. The sea is almost mystical to people like my dad, and O'Brian would only get respect from them with such detail. Great episode, it reminded me of my late father.”

Jen agreed: “Fiction isn't designed as a manual for these things, but they exist to build out the world. I think that by investing yourself in the story, often you find that you start to understand what the terms you need to know mean by living in the words of the book.”

A good chunk of you admitted too much research can get in the way of a good read. Kris said: “It shouldn’t be a technical manual, unless of course it is a technical manual. A great novel is defined by the writer’s ability to make you feel what the characters are feeling regardless of genre.”

Ranking the book, the clear majority awarded this book 8/10.

Jen began reading O’Brian’s novels after “a lot of convincing from my dad” but said: “I love the way the books intermingle the history of the period in the background of what is happening and that none of the truly big events of the period appear in the lives of our protagonists, but are there present in the background as flavour.”

Clint praised the books, writing: “I found that this series, much like Austen's writing, has a high ‘must read this quote to whomever is around’ coefficient. There are just so many pithy turns of phrase scattered throughout.”

We loved this review from a commenter who gave it 9/10. “Picture this,” she wrote. “A female executive in her mid 30s. She’s travelling, working hard and playing... well... hard. She sees the film so reads the book. The world of Captain Jack Aubrey and his best friend/ship’s surgeon Stephen Maturin becomes an obsession. All 21 books are devoured within seven months. And she genuinely said – when asked in a review what she most wished to be – that it was a Napoleonic-era Captain of the Royal Navy. This book was a bolt from the blue and a treasured revelation. Who said modern women can’t dream of adventure on the high seas?”

Best of friends

As our presenters and many of you noted, the friendship between Aubrey and Maturin is the heart of these books – so we asked for your favourite literary friendships, which you sent with zeal.

“The relationship between Ishmael and Queequeg in Moby Dick stands out – the mutual recognition of inherent humanity and brotherhood despite radical difference is just so moving,” said Karen.

Lyra Silvertongue and Will Parry from Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy was one of Jill’s picks. “I love the way Pullman manages to bring two totally different characters together and also still manages to bring in clever parallels between them. It starts off grumpy almost, develops into respect, then real friendship and finally love by the end of the Amber Spyglass. I never got over the ending.”

“For my money, the greatest depiction of male friendship in any book is in The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay by Michael Chabon,” said Colin. “Two cousins – one from Prague, one from Brooklyn – scale the giddy heights of the golden age of comic books in war time NYC.”

“In its own way I think Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas [by Hunter S. Thompson] is a picture of a very real male friendship,” says Rod. “One of them is a complete liability but the other puts up with them despite this, makes excuses and looks after them and neither talks about how they feel.”

And though not literary, several of you wrote in to suggest Captain Kirk and Mr Spock from Star Trek. Ben said: “A pair of characters devised completely independently of Captain Aubrey and Dr Maturin, but at about the same time. The parallels between Aubrey and Kirk are obvious. But consider Spock as well. Like Maturin he is of mixed heritage. He is highly intelligent, devoted to science, and cold on the surface but heaving with hidden passions. Also like Maturin, he is also surprisingly dangerous in a fight.”

Austen at sea

After Tabby joined the critics who saw more than shades of Austen in O’Brian’s novels, Johanna agreed that she “thought of them as a masculine side of Georgian life that would have been experienced by Jane Austen’s brothers, some of whom went to sea.” She wrote: “They must have come back and told Jane, Cassandra and the wider family of their shipboard experiences, of the type and in the tone and language so carefully recreated by O’Brian. Frederick Wentworth and his brother-in-law Admiral Croft in Persuasion would fit perfectly in Jack Aubrey’s world of passionate seafaring excitement and personal fortune making.”

On a point of technicality

After we discussed the difficulty of O’Brian’s naval language and suggested pleasure was found by skipping over it lightly, many of you wrote in to suggest otherwise.

Deborah wrote: “To those of us who are familiar with sailing, the scenes about life aboard ship, manoeuvring them and climbing their rigging were thrilling; particularly the battle scenes! To see the amazing expertise and teamwork that it took to fight a heated battle using only the wind to move your ship in the desired direction was so very interesting. To understand how the wind and the motion of both your own ship and your enemy's ship were so important leading up to and during the fight was awesome. The knowledge of precisely when to fire the cannons (using the swell or the trough of the wave to aim correctly) was amazing. And the advantage of the weather helm! Talk to any sailor who has read the books and they'll agree.”

“Neither male nor conservative”

After Dominic commented that the series largely appeals to men (and likely conservative men), some female O’Brian lovers wrote in to have their say.

“I am a 60-something woman and first came to these books in my forties,” said Ros. “I have read every one in the series. But another comment from Dominic made my heart sing. Picking up one of these novels is like the comfort of visiting old friends for that is exactly how I feel. The friendship between Jack and Stephen, their adventures on the high seas and the eclectic cast of characters, not least of those being Jack's wife Sophie and Diana Villiers, are a joy to read.”

Heather added that she was a fan “despite not being male or particularly conservative” – she read them after her husband started picking them up, and finished the whole series in a year. “I love reading about the insular, claustrophobic, extreme world of the Royal Navy. The negative sides are shown in all their gory detail (floggings, abuse of teenage boys, driving out of men who didn't fit into the group), but the positives are astounding – the resourcefulness of men who literally rebuilt their ships at sea in extreme conditions, and the bravery of those who stood up wearing brightly coloured uniforms in a wooden vessel, facing heavy cannon fire, while their shipmates got shot to pieces all around them.”

She concluded: “I just wanted to say how pleased I was to hear Dominic describe himself getting emotional at the scene of Jack's ordeal in the stocks, at the end of The Reverse of the Medal. I sobbed like a baby when I read that scene – I thought maybe I was just hormonal at the time, but now I'm glad to know I had company. Those moments are so moving because they feel so earned by the whole sweep of the series.”

Literary comfort

Nigel says the podcast has inspired him to embark on his fourth re-read of the series. He wrote: “Like Dominic, PO'B is something of a comfort blanket read for me. His prose is elegant, and I like the Age of Enlightenment wordiness of his dialogue. Moreover, his principal characters are all just nice guys with whom it's a joy to spend some spare hours. What is particularly engaging, though, is how distinct each character's voice is, and how that imparts their personality.”

Go audio

Several of you recommended the audiobooks of the series. Stuart says: “20 years ago I had a four-hour daily commute and used audiobooks to satisfy my reading appetite. By far the most memorable series was that of Patrick O’Brian’s 20-book series. Indeed, I used to arrive home in the evenings and sit in the car listening to them, unable to prise myself out!

“The main character narrator was Patrick Tull who gave me such a brilliant characterisation of both Jack Aubrey and Stephen Maturin that on the odd occasion when one of the series was read by someone different I felt the characters became somewhat foreign.”

Scoreboard

Book

Dominic’s Verdict

Tabby’s Verdict

To Kill a Mockingbird

9/10

9/10

Master and Commander

8/10

7/10

The Catcher in the Rye

6/10

7.5/10

The Shining

6/10

6.5/10

White Nights

4/10

6/10

Next on The Book Club

If you or your book club want to read ahead, here’s what’s coming up in the podcast over the next few weeks…

  • November 24: Money by Martin Amis

  • December 1: Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy by John Le Carré

  • December 8: Tess of the d’Urbervilles by Thomas Hardy

  • December 15: Dune by Frank Herbert

  • December 22: Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone by J. K. Rowling

  • December 29: A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess

Keeping score

This week, Dominic and Tabby both awarded To Kill a Mockingbird 9/10 syrupy biscuits. But what did you think?

Click to vote – Please LEAVE YOUR NAME if you comment, so we can share your thoughts in next week's newsletter.

Login or Subscribe to participate

See you next week for Money.

The Book Club Team